I have been following with interest the news that Paris (or rather, the Paris suburbs) is rioting.

The basic story is familiar - some kids were killed, perhaps while being chased by police. The kids were (not white), and the cops were. Add a little poverty and inequality, and boom!

The story has an interesting resonance here in the state of Michigan, as a recent ruling has cleared a ballot initiative which would amend the state constitution, making it illegal to hire based on race or gender.

This 'anti-affirmative-action' amendment, as it is being called, cuts right to the heart of the philisophical difference between France and the United States when it comes to questions of race. In the US, it has been decided (or perhaps I should say 'in the past it was thought') that the disadvantages faced by minorities (racism, sexism, etc) must be addressed in an active way - preferential treatment in hiring, for example. In France, on the contrary, it is illegal to even ask - everyone is a citizen of the republic, and thus the same. This treatment goes so far as to make asking the question illegal, which is why the number of Muslims in France is unknown. It is, to some extent, the old 'melting pot vs. salad bowl' debate.

I would argue, and you are free to disagree, that the French experiment is a failure. Further, I would offer that it should guide us in thinking about the question of minorities here in Michigan. 'Equal' treatment doesn't happen.

Anonymous commented:
Sarkozy talked about "la discrimination positive à la française" about 4 days before the riots began. He declared that a program would start hiring youth from disadvantaged neighbourhoods for police training. (http://fr.news.yahoo.com/26102005/290/nicolas-sarkozy-pour-la-discrimination-positive-a-la-francaise.html) Hope all is well - anaïs
on Fri Nov 4 16:30:19 2005

David commented:
That's really funny! Isn't he also the one taking a hard line on the rioters? And his immigration policies are also... more stringent than I might like. I wouldn't have thought he would be an affirmative action kind of guy....

I quite enjoyed his comments in the article 'denouncing "le blocage de l'ascenseur social"'. It has a nice ring when translated!

on Fri Nov 4 17:40:14 2005

Add a Comment
Back to the Blog